Valarie Hays is a trial attorney and former federal prosecutor who represents companies and individuals in government investigations and complex commercial litigation and assists corporate clients with the development and execution of their compliance programs, including conducting internal investigations. Valarie has experience in a wide variety of industries, including healthcare, financial services, and oil and gas.
Over the course of her legal career, Valarie has tried 16 federal jury trials, argued cases before the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals, and conducted over 150 investigations. She has deep experience handling matters involving the False Claims Act, the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, and banking and environmental regulatory issues.
Valarie is known for her strong courtroom presence and ability to find and leverage the hidden weaknesses in the government’s and her opponents’ cases. Strategic thinking skills and attention to detail have driven her results. Her last three criminal cases ended with the government dismissing the charges against her clients with prejudice, a rare occurrence in the federal system. In addition, she has successfully obtained numerous prosecution declinations for corporations and executive level employees where they faced substantial risk of prosecution. Valarie’s clients also trust her to handle their most sensitive compliance matters and internal investigations. She understands the value clients place on efficiently obtaining the necessary information while minimizing disruption to their businesses during the investigations.
Honorable Suzanne Conlon, District Judge, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois (2000 – 2001)
- On the eve of trial, convincing government to dismiss federal indictment charging Vice President of a bank with loan fraud after filing defense motions in limine.
- Convincing the government to dismiss an indictment for wire fraud after defending the client in a federal criminal trial that resulted in a hung jury.
- Convincing the government to dismiss indictment charging real estate developer with violations of the Clean Air Act; the government originally was seeking a sentence of over nine years; after we prevailed on the eve of trial on evidentiary rulings that were unfavorable to the government, the case was resolved with the client pleading to a misdemeanor and no jail time.
- Convincing the government to decline charges against individual being investigated for False Claims Act violations.
- Convincing the government to decline prosecution of a gas company under federal investigation for Clean Water Act violations.
- Convincing the government to dismiss charges against an oil and gas trader charged with market manipulation.
- Obtaining favorable multi-million-dollar settlements for a corporate client as a result of negligent acts committed by bank directors and officers.
- Representing multiple public global companies in developing their FCPA compliance programs and investigating potential FCPA violations, including in the Middle East, Europe, and Asia.
- Representing a healthcare company in a government investigation involving fraud committed by the company’s top executives. The investigation concluded with no charges against the company.
- Representing executives in government investigations related to the Deepwater Horizon rig explosion and oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico. The investigations concluded with no charges or other adverse actions against the executives.
- Representing global company and executive in a U.S. Department of Justice bid rigging investigation. The investigation concluded with no charges.
- Representing doctor in a government investigation involving alleged billing improprieties. The investigation concluded with no charges.
- Representing a hospital in investigating and responding to a hostage situation.
- Representing a large private university in investigating and responding to a student death after hazing incidents.
- Representing a police department in investigating internal complaints of harassment and discrimination and evaluating the department’s policies and procedures.
- Representing a company and individuals in government investigations related to alleged Minority Business Enterprise (“MBE”) fraud.
- Representing individual under federal investigation for bankruptcy fraud.
- Representing individual in a federal indictment charging tax fraud.
- Representing a healthcare company in a Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (“RICO”) lawsuit.
- Representing a medical device manufacturer in investigating allegations of false statements to government officials.
- Representing a healthcare company in investigating allegations of whistleblower discrimination.
Harvard Law School, J.D., 2000
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, B.A., 1997, summa cum laude
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Florida
U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois (Trial Bar)
U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana
U.S. District Court for the Western District of Michigan
Professional MembershipsAmerican Bar Association
Section of Litigation
Corporate Counsel Committee
Criminal Justice Section
White Collar Crime Committee
Federal Bar Association
Former Board of Directors
Finance and Governance Committee
Harvard Law Society of Illinois
Board of Directors
National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
Women's White Collar Defense Association (WWCDA)
Honors & Awards
Illinois Leading Lawyer, Law Bulletin Media Leading Lawyers (2018-2020)
Illinois Super Lawyers, Thomson Reuters (2017-2020)
Illinois Rising Stars, Thomson Reuters' Illinois Super Lawyers (2013-2015)
Illinois Emerging Lawyer, Law Bulletin Media Leading Lawyers (2015)
“Nursing Homes Must Prepare For Risk Of FCA Liability,” (author) Law360 Commentary (April 21, 2020)
10th Annual DOJ & SEC Enforcement 2017 Update, (panelist) (May 18, 2017)
“Recent Developments In White Collar Criminal Matters in the Central and Midwest Regions,” (moderator) ABA White Collar Conference (March 2016)
“Successful Women Lawyers,” (panelist) Lake County Bar Association Seminar (December 3,2015)
“Best Practices for Effective Anti‐Corruption Due Diligence and Monitoring in High Risk Countries,” (panelist) American Conference Institute’s FCPA Boot Camp (June 2015)
“Update on Enforcement of Books & Records Provision of the FCPA and How to Strengthen Internal Accounting Controls,” (panelist) FCPA Boot Camp, American Conference Institute (June 2014)
“Current Trends in Whistleblower Law,” Corporate In‐House Training (July 2013)
“Developing a Corporate Compliance Program to Ensure Compliance with Anti‐Bribery Laws in the United States, the United Kingdom, and Canada,” Corporate In‐House Training (May 2013)
“Current Developments in FCPA Enforcement,” (panelist) Journal of International Law and Business Roundtable, Northwestern Law School (April 2013)
“Ensuring Compliance with the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and Other Anti‐Bribery Laws,” Corporate In‐House Training (March 2013)
“The Clean Water Act, Clean Air Act, and Endangered Species Act: Environmental Compliance,” Corporate In‐House Training (March 2013)
“Addressing Whistleblower Risk,” Corporate In‐House Training (February 2013)
“Whistleblowers in Today’s Workplace,” Corporate In‐House Training (January 2013)
“Ensuring Ethical and Corruption‐Free Practices,” (panelist) Bankers Accuity Presentation (October 2012)
“How to Conduct Internal Investigations,” Corporate In‐House Training (April 2012)
CASA Lake County, Former Board of Directors
Federal Defenders, Panel Member